Saturday, June 02, 2007

TEN CANOES - tricksy Aborigine folk tale

TEN CANOES runs rings around its audience. It starts with a beautiful slow sweeping shot of a river winding through lush almost luminous grass. An aborigine narrator, David Gulpilil, opens with a fairytale: "Once upon a time...." and then immediately checks our expectations with a "no, it's not that kind of story!" The narrator baits us with the promise of a great story, but at the same time holds it distant from us. It's not our kind of story but his story. And amidst all this talk of a story he firmly refuses to get on with it! No, we must wait and do things his way, starting at the very beginning, with the aborigine creation story.

After this prologue, we move back in time to the era of the narrator's grandparents. In black and white, we see aborigine men out on a hunting expedition. They are stripping the bark off trees to make canoes in order to gather goose-eggs. The scenes look like images from old anthropology textbooks and the patient narration has a quasi-nature doc. feel to it. But before we fall into the trap of imagining the aborigines as naive, innocent children of the earth, they start cracking jokes about farts, small pricks, impotence and gluttonous grandfathers (the scene-stealing Richard Birrinbirrin). It transpires that Dayindi (Jamie Galpilil) is after his elder brother Minygululu's pretty young third wife. So Minygululu tells Dayindi a salutory tale to teach him "to live proper." And that's the tale that the narrator, FINALLY, is going to tell us.

So, once again, we shift back even further in time to the ancients, where another brother is lusting after his elder brother's wife. We're back in colour and it seems to a modern audience that we might finally be getting somewhere. Of course, the narrator can't help cutting back to the goose-egg gathering, or making wry comments. But the tale does flower, with plenty of humour and not a little pathos.

Eventually, the story comes to its conclusion. The narrator teases us again: "And they all lived happily ever after." Of course, he's joking. But the interesting part for me was that as much as the narrator wants to distance us from this very different tale, it has the same sort of pat moral as your typical European folk tale. Small world, eh?

TEN CANOES played Toronto, London and Cannes, where it won the Un Certain Regard prize for 2006. It opened in Italy, Australia, Greece, Norway and France in 2006. It opened in the Netherlands and Belgium earlier this year and is crrently on release in the UK and US. It opens in Germany on August 9th 2007.

Friday, June 01, 2007

Who is Slavoj ZIZEK!?

I noticed, I’m idiot at some level, by idiot I mean psychotic, I take things literallyZIZEK! is a short (70 minute) but intense documentary that serves to answer the question: who is Slavoj Zizek?

Slavoj Zizek began his public life as a Slovenian dissident in the 1980s. He was blacklisted, unable to find work in academia, and finally forced to take a job for the Central Committee. But after the fall of Communism his career blossomed - ironic seeing as he remains a convinced Marxist philosopher. He even stood for the Slovenian presidency and nearly won. However, he is not a politician so much as a political and cultural theorist.

Zizek is not any old Marxist: he is also a Lacanian. Not that he agrees with Lacan's apparently pompous style of delivery - as demonstrated in the documentary with clips from a lecture broadcast on French state TV. But Zizek agrees with the substance of Lacan's theory of psychoanalysis. The difference is that Zizek applies psychoanalytical theory not just to the relationship between private individuals, but to the influence of the anonymous social whole on private individual's conscious and unconscious desires. In practical terms, how do social phenomena - movies, adverts, terrorist attacks - impinge on our individual make-up?

Within certain circles, Zizek has achieved the status of a rock-star philosopher. He gives sell-out lectures in crammed auditoriums. Young students clamber over each other just to touch him or to get his autograph. No doubt part of his appeal lies in his memorable oratorical style: the thick Slovenian accent, the lisp, the intense eyes, the manic hand gestures, the slightly clown-ish aspect to his love of the extreme phrase. It is this TV friendly package, as well as Zizek's willingness to apply his highly developed theories to movies we've seen, that have given him a certain visibility.

In the documentary, Zizek says he hates his notoriety. He fears that by indulging his clown-like nature, his opponents have made a straw man. If the public sees Zizek as a shocking, funny posturer, they won't take him seriously as a philosopher. He argues that he almost needs to commit public suicide - to kill off the persona that has made a documentary like this inevitable - in order to get back to his roots. Then again, his willingness to mock up a suicide for the closing shot of the film, suggests that his love of mischief will always get the better of him.

I think it would be a shame if Zizek lost his ability to shock and amuse. He is one of the few philosophers who is able to speak to a wide audience in clear English and to convey interesting, thought-provoking ideas. If he needs to clown around to get our attention and tell us about the modern relevance of Marx' theory of commodity fetishism, then so be it. I'd rather have the complete Zizek than either dry theory or empty pop cinema. Still, this dilemma - how the artist can retain his integrity while also remaining popular - is interesting. It's the same issue we saw debated, albeit under a different guise, in JOE STRUMMER: THE FUTURE IS UNWRITTEN. So for all those interested in philosophy, psychology or the nature of fame in the modern era, ZIZEK! is essential viewing.

ZIZEK! was released in Germany earlier this year and is currently on release in the UK. It is available on Region 1 DVD.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

The cinema of Nagesh Kukunoor.

My recent post on the Madhur Bandharkar's Mumbai trilogy, led me to reconsider my experience of Indian art-house cinema and prompted this post on the recent cinema of writer-director-actor Nagesh Kukunoor. They are two complementary directors. Bandharkar's cinema seeks to expose corruption at the very heights of Indian society. He uses fast cuts, hand-held cameras and the brash confrontational structure of investigative journalism. The over-riding tone is angry. By contrast, Kukunoor's cinema deals is more quiet, more personal, more sentimental and less polished.


Kukunoor's first film was his incredibly lo-fi 1998 feature, HYDERABADI BLUES. He plays the protagonist - a young Indian man who returns home after a decade in the US and finds himself bewildered by the traditional process of wooing a wife. Kukunoor shows his flair for comic dialogue and for creating authentic emotional dilemmas. But the film falls down for its ridiculous denouement and the rough-and-ready technical spec. So this is arguably an interesting movie for fans of his later work, rather than a must-see for general audiences.

Kukunoor's next movie was the 1999 coming of age tragicomedy, ROCKFORD. It's about pre-teen boys in an Indian all-boys Catholic boarding school. Kukunoor captures the dramas of growing up in a strict environment, friendship and first love with candour and wit. But this is a less successful film that HYDERABADI BLUES. Although filmed on a larger budget, the editing and framing still have a haphazard feel. The plot was a bit random too. Big issues, such as sexual abuse, are introduced and then neatly dismissed. And the lead actors, young Rohan Dey and Nandita Das give mediocre performances.

Next up is the 2001 satire on Bollywood, BOLLYWOOD CALLING. Pat Cusick plays himself - a failed Hollywood actor who decides to take bit part in a Bollywood movie directed a has-been played by the legendary Om Puri. Once again, the technical package ratchets up a notch in this flick, though far from perfect. Still, it was a testament to Kukunoor's increasing success that he managed to cast Om Puri. The script is especially good on the culture clash between East and West and in lightly mocking the intrinsic ridiculous of the Bollywood masala movie. But there is no rage and no anger - no exploration of the darker side of an industry with mafia links and a bad track record on sexual abuse. Instead we get a very schmaltzy denouement where, once again, all loose ends tie up neatly and in the best of all worlds. I mean, you don't have to make a movie as fierce as PAGE THREE, which is less a satire than a rant. But, BOLLYWOOD CALLING isn't half as perceptive, accomplished, visually inventive or tragicomic as Merchant Ivory's 1970 classic, BOMBAY TALKIE, for instance.

2003 brought a turnaround in Kukunoor's career, as far as I am concerned. With the dark thriller 3 DEEWAREIN (3 WALLS) he made a movie of real emotional depth and political importance. It is powered by surprisingly good performance from mainstream Bollywood actors - Jackie Shroff, Juhi Chawla and Gulshan Grover - as well as a typically brilliant performance from Naseerudin Shah. The movie opens with a no-nonsense depiction of three murders. We then move forward in time. Chawla plays an abused housewife who is interviewing three convicts on India's death row. They are played by Shroff, Shah and - in an absurd lack of humility on his part - Kukunoor. The thriller aspect arises from why exactly the woman is so interested in these men. The tension builds - there are no silly songs to destract from it - until a powerful and uncharacteristically dark denoument. The result is an accomplished and powerful film that breaks the Bollywood mould and is definitely worth trying to watch. Indeed, the only real flaw is Kukunoor's reluctance to cast a better actor than himself in a lead role.
After such a promising film it is disheartening to say that in 2004, Kukunoor released a flimsy cash-in - HYDERABADI BLUES 2. The least said about this mediocre feel-good nonsense the better. But things went from bad to worse with the admittedly critically acclaimed 2005 schmaltz-fest IQBAL. This is a polished, emotionally manipulative, hackneyed underdog/sports movie. Picking up from the plucky young things in LAGAAN, here we have a deaf-mute boy who triumphs over his family's objections to play for the Indian cricket team having been talent-spotted by no less a legend than Kapil Dev! Seriously.

But before we can write off Kukunoor as a Bollywood Spielberg-lite, he flip-flops back to form with this 2006 flick, DOR. Ayesha Takia plays a naive and kind-hearted Hindu girl called Meera who marries her childhood sweetheart. She lives with his highly traditional (for which read patriarchal and oppressive) family while her husband leaves home to look for work in a factory. But soon they receive the news that the husband is dead. He was apparently pushed from a balcony by his room-mate, a Muslim man from north India. Meera is now a young widow - at the lowest rung of the social ladder - and kept as a quasi-slave in her husband's house. Still, she does not object to this until she meets a North Indian woman called Zeenat (Gul Kirat Panang). Zeenat is a feminist Muslim who teaches her to have some fun and think for herself. However, Zeenat has a hidden agenda. Her husband has been convicted of killing Meera's husband and the only way she can save him from the death sentence is to persuade Meera to pardon him.

The movie is beautifully filmed and shows the difference in landscape, culture and customs of Himachal Pradesh and Rajasthan. DP Sudeep Chatterjee does excellent work. The script and the two lead performances are also praise-worthy. In particular, Meera's awakening is subtle and convincing. All in all, DOR is a quiet, patient, lyrical film that, along with 3 DEEWAREIN, makes Kukunoor a director that it's hard to dismiss.

All these films are available on DVD.

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

CONVERSATIONS WITH OTHER WOMEN - stylish adult drama

CONVERSATIONS WITH OTHER WOMEN is that rare thing - an intelligent, witty, perceptive drama. Even more rare, it is a movie with a technical conceit that adds to its emotional weight, rather than simply being a gimmick.

The plot is simple. Two people who once had a relationship meet by chance at a wedding many years later. They start flirting, have sex and then part.

The technical conceit is that the movie is shown in two separate vertical panels. Even when the protagonists are having sex, they are shown on separate screens. Sometimes, they speak to each other in one panel, while the other panel shows the people they are talking about or flashes back to their previous relationship. Other times, one of the protagonists will play out two responses to the same act in each panel.

The editing together of the two panels - by director Hans Canosa - really makes you think about the interior lives of the protagonists. We become highly conscious about how much they have changed since they first met - physically and emotionally - and the impact their meetings have had on each other. The conceit also serves to deliver one of the most imaginatively shown sex scenes in cinema.

I love that the film uses the split screen to explore the nature of memory, missed chances, and ageing. I love that the script is truthful rather than sentimental. I love the occasional flashes of comedy from Olivia Wilde as an uptight bridesmaid and Thomas Lennon as the wedding videographer. But at its core, this movie is a showcase for the actors, and Helena Bonham Carter and Aaron Eckhart deliver performances that are brave, incisive and thought provoking.

CONVERSATIONS WITH OTHER WOMEN went on release in France, Canada, the US, and Israel in 2006. It opened in South Korea, Japan, Turkey, Singapore and Belgium earlier this year. It is currently on release in the UK. The movie is also available on Region 1 DVD.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

FLYBOYS - less Flash, more Heart

FLYBOYS is a war movie so old-fashioned, earnest and two-dimensional it brought a nostalgic tear to my eye. It's a no-nonsense, patriotic, sentimental true story about Americans who flew fighter planes for the French before the US joined World War One. The American heroes are clean-cut handsome men who wear nice uniforms. That is, unless they're the quirky, weedy soldiers who are bound to get shot down by the evil Hun and provide the movie's pathos.

On the down-side, the handsome young things are led by James Franco, who once again does that handsome brooding thing that he sub's for acting. The inevitable romance between Franco and a young French peasant-girl is pure sugar and lengthens the movie's run-time from a manageable 90 minutes to well over two hours. There's a hamfisted attempt to explore the racial politics of the time. Plus, the dialogue is pretty dire. (Suprising given that one of the writers penned SLEEPLESS IN SEATTLE.)

But despite these manifest flaws, FLYBOYS is not a complete waste of time. First and foremost, after revisionist movies like FLAGS OF OUR FATHERS it's quite nice to remember that sometimes there are simply young men who display courage fighting for what they believe in with no hidden agenda. But second, let's not under-estimate how much fun it is to see handsome men in nice uniforms have brilliantly rendered dog fights. Because, if there's only one thing that director Tony Bill gets right, he REALLY gets the battle sequences right. And by "right", I don't mean historically right - I'm sure you could pick apart the exact types of planes used - but exhilerating. Pure and simple. DP Henry Braham and the CGI boys should be proud.

So, for those of you who enjoy watching pilots shoot at each other in rickety planes - who love lovers kissing at sunset and tales of derring-do - this is your film. For all its flaws, by not trying to be too clever, it retains a certain charm.

FLYBOYS was released in the US, Philippines, Greece, Estonia, Latvia, Turkey, Slovenia, Russia, Brazil, Hungary, Thailand, Iceland, Hong Kong, Romania and Singapore in 2005. It opened in Mexico, Australia, Poland, Germany and Belgium earlier this year. It opens in the UK on June 1st and in Italy and Spain on June 29th. FLYBOYS is available on Region 1 DVD.

Monday, May 28, 2007

WEDDING DAZE - stealth comedy

There's something about WEDDING DAZE that defies the ludicrous premise. The idea is that a grieving fiance, prompted by his best friend's pleas to start dating again, asks the next girl he meets to marry him. Ridiculously, she says yes. And so they set off for a wedding chapel in Atlantic City with some kooky best friends, a jailbird dad and some cops in tow. Jason Biggs and Isla Fisher are just so darned likeable as the goofy lovers that you can't help rooting for them. Michael Weston and Ebon Moss-Bachrach are so quietly funny as their respective best friends that you can't help chuckling. In fairness, the whole Jewish toy gag and Joe Pantoliano/jailbird storyline left me cold. But what's not to like about Edward Herrmann and Margot Martindale playing Biggs' sexually voracious parents?

I'm not pretending that I laughed myself silly, but anything that makes you smile at the end and chuckle more than a couple of times has its merits.

WEDDING DAZE aka THE PLEASURE OF YOUR COMPANY played Toronto 2006. It opens in the UK on June 1st, in the US on September 17th, in Belgium on September 19th and in the Netherlands on September 20th.