Lance Oppenheim (PRIMETIME) and Nathan Fielder have created a sensational film - neither documentary nor scripted drama - but rather a meta-inquiry as to the nature of knowing and of documentaries themselves. The nebulous nature of the film's format, defying categorisation, will perhaps scupper its chances at awards season. No matter. This is rightly being hyped as a must-watch film.
So let's begin with the first layer of the narrative: the one we bring with us as we enter the cinema. That is of Elizabeth Holmes as a nasty psychopathic fraudster who created a fake medical device, raised millions to fund it, and put patient health at risk. A woman who was happy to destroy lives to protect her nasty secret, and was rightly put behind bars.
The second layer of the narrative takes up the first half of this film. It's actually a counter-narrative that serves Elizabeth's purposes. Rather than being an evil duplicitous mastermind, she is actually a neurodivergent innocent, exploited by nasty manipulative men (Sunny Balwani during her Theranos years, her partner Billy now) and falsely convicted for crimes she did not commit.
The third layer of narrative takes up the second half of the film, and is propelled by real-life actress Amanda Seyfried, who famously played Elizabeth in the Hulu miniseries The Dropout. Seyfried serves as an avatar for the audience's shocked reaction to the events of the first half of the film. This moves us into questioning whether Elizabeth was really manipulating us in the first half of the film, and indeed manipulating Billy as she manipulated Sunny, to be patsies for her. Just think "egg-beating-scene".
The fourth layer of narrative comes either toward the end of the film or when we leave. When we start to wonder whether Amanda Seyfried was ever being "real" or was performing from a script after all. And this then gets us to the whole point of the film which is to question everything. Whether we can ever really "know" and whether a documentary format can ever really get us to "knowledge" at all.
It's a total mindfuck of a film and a conversation-starter. That's the point. We can all have our views of Elizabeth. I think she's a psychopath. Her partner Billy is also clearly some kind of Maga-supporting fraudster too. But in a sense that's not the point of the film. It needs to be seen, experienced, and talked about.
YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING is rated R and has a running time of 174 minutes. It is on global release.
