Director Ben Taylor (Sex Education) and writer Jack Thorne (ENOLA HOLMES) deliver a rather earnest but tepid biopic about the scientists who developed IVF. Maybe earnestness is what this topic requires, but it does rather strain the two-hour running time.
The cast is, however, mostly great. James Norton plays biologist Robert Edwards, fizzing with excitement and energy and impatient with barriers. He teams up with near-retirement obstetrician Dr Patrick Steptoe (an understated and moving Bill Nighy) whose ability to delicately extract the candidates' eggs allows Edwards to attempt to fertilise them in vitro. Tanya Moodie is wonderfully stern and pragmatic as the fictional NHS Nurse who has to manage the patients and the ward. The only weak link is Thomasin McKenzie as the real-life research nurse who project managed the entire affair, Jean Purdy. There is something in her line delivery that I found unconvincing.
My suspicion is that there is a far more interesting film to be made about the opposition to the research - whether religious (represented here by Purdy's mother - an always excellent Joanna Scanlan) - scientific - or simply bureaucratic. We get some of that here but it is rather lightly skated over. I also feel that the film would have been more interesting if it had focussed on why Jean Purdy was not given due recognition for decades and despite Edwards' campaigning. Basically I wanted something grittier and more nuanced than the rather Keep Calm and Carry On plain vanilla approach taken here.
JOY has a running time of 115 minutes, is rated PG-13, and was released on Netflix last month.
No comments:
Post a Comment